default header

Submissions

[PC] Ancient Domains of Mystery

Moderator: JC Denton

[PC] Ancient Domains of Mystery

Unread postby vdate » 27 Dec 2009 00:15

Ancient Domains of Mystery
Rating:*****

Emanating from the Draklor Chain of mountains, Chaos is spreading, covering the land. Many heroes have tried to investigate the cause, but none have returned. As a fresh-faced young @ sign of a race and class of your choice, your goal is to enter the Draklor Chain, investigate and deal with the Chaos problem, and leave alive.

Ancient Domains of Mystery (ADOM) is a dungeon crawling game of the Roguelike sub-genre. As befits one of the big names Roguelikes it retains the random dungeon generation, randomly labeled treasure, turn based mechanics, ASCII graphics, and permanent character death that typify the sub-genre. Grinding is not encouraged as it is in the Bands, and items often have alternate uses for the clever to deduce. If this sounds awfully familiar to you Nethack fans, you would be right. However, most of ADOM's differences from Nethack are also ADOM's selling points.

Gone are the variety of don/doff commands for different types of equipment. The inventory screen presents a lettered list of slots, and pressing the appropriate key empties it or brings up a list of possible equipment, making equipment changing much smoother. Sacrificing and piety have been expanded from the 'Nethack standard', with anything from live sacrifices to gold pieces to rocks being valid fodder, and your deity dictating which gifts will be in favour and which will not. Artifacts are available in greater variety and with stranger effects than in Nethack, and a different and interesting class of 'magic' has been introduced in Mindcraft. Finally, there is ambient magical radiation in the Chain- stay there too long, and your character will start to mutate. While most mutations carry advantages as well as disadvantages, being mutated too heavily will result in transformation into a horrible Chaos blob, ending the game. This radiation gets more intense as one approaches the source and ways to remove corruption are rare. Thus, there is an anti-grinding mechanism in place, since tarrying too long gaining levels and treasure means that that character may be unable to race the 'corruption clock' to the final objective.

Other Roguelikes tend to be mostly linear- get to the bottom of the dungeon, beat the Big Bad or grab the magical mystery McGuffin, and get to the exit with your hide intact. ADOM takes another route, giving access to an overworld map with pre-placed locations, some necessary, some not. While the objective of the game is made clear to the player, the mechanism whereby this is accomplished is not. Thus, gathering information and exploring the overworld map become an integral part of the (unspoiled) game. The areas not vital to the completion of the game allow also ADOM to allow skilled players a chance to increase the risk/reward factor. For players for whom even this is old hat, there are secret endgame objectives that dramatically increase the game's difficulty for an extra challenge.

Finally, a number of changes have been made to promote greater variety in the tactics available to different characters. A great variety of skills are available to increase at level up (40 total), and of those skills, 31 are not directly related to combat. Instead, they tend more along the lines of Stealth, Herbalism, or Bridge Building- all allowing players to advance without necessarily engaging in combat. A character's race and class determine the skills available to them, further differentiating characters. Greater character customization also occurs through talents available at certain levels and at character creation, similar to Fallout's 'perks'- little bonuses like more starting gold or a greater healing rate that change how a character might play. Last, while a character's statistics are in large part determined by their race, the twenty classes are distinguished by class-specific intrinsic advantages available at certain levels. For example, while a Fighter gets an additional 7% more 'armour value' out of all of his gear at level 6, at the same level, a Barbarian learns a powerful but slow attack, a Paladin learns to cure sickness, and a Beastfighter becomes resistant to poison, and these powers rarely overlap. All these features add to the already considerable replay value of the game.

Finally, ADOM is challenging. While this may not be news to those familiar with Roguelikes, it is a game for which simple completion is a real accomplishment. Most players of ADOM will actually never beat it, because it shows no qualms about throwing monsters at the character well above their ability to handle without clever use of all the resources- intrinsic powers, spells, consumable items, and good tactics- available to them. It is this point that brings the game together. All the above features and mechanics would be fun but ultimately unimportant unless the player actually needed to use them. By threatening the player with the erasure of all their hard-earned progress at every turn, the game creates white-knuckled tension that most turn-based games would find impossible to match, and rewards those who learn from past experiences and integrate their hard-earned knowledge into their play. Anyone who likes dungeon crawlers and would appreciate a game that rewards careful thought and integrating past experience into one's tactics would do well to give ADOM a try.
Last edited by vdate on 27 Dec 2009 22:48, edited 2 times in total.
vdate
 
Joined: 26 Dec 2009 22:02

Unread postby icycalm » 27 Dec 2009 13:56

First off, edit out the word gameplay. If you post it again I'll ban you.

Second, it is impossible for me to read this "review". You'd be better off posting it here:

http://wikipedia.org/

Imagine what would happen if every time I wanted to review something I wrote as if I was talking to someone who had no idea what the fuck I was talking about.

"Let's review Final Fight! Final Fight is a Videogame! Because some readers might not know what a Videogame is I will explain it! And I will also explain how the English language works, because some random person from the Congo might pick it up!"

I mean Jesus Fucking Christ.

Like I said: what you want to do is become a Wikipedia editor.

Have you even read any of our reviews on this site?

Note: on reading this review over before posting, it's at least half a review of classic Roguelikes as a whole as opposed to ADOM in particular. However, I think this is unavoidable


If you are an incompetent reviewer, yes. But I can review a bullet-hell game just fine without reviewing the entire genre. In fact I have already done this, and several times.

one's choice of Roguelike is largely a matter of how much one enjoys the game-specific tweaks to the Roguelike formula, but the formula is essential to the high-challenge, thought-rewarding nature of the genre.


My advice to you: stop scribbling and read some reviews here. Read the Mars Matrix review: 5-6 succinct paragraphs that review THE GAME, not Wikipedify its genre. I mean you are not even REVIEWING the genre -- you are just Wikipedifying it. Which is why your "review" is practically illegible.

This is also my first Insomnia forum post and my first full review of anything, so feedback would be appreciated.


It is not a matter of you wanting or not wanting "feedback". YOU ARE SUBMITTING A REVIEW FOR PUBLICATION ON THIS SITE. OF COURSE YOU WILL GET "FEEDBACK". WHETHER YOU WANT TO OR NOT.
User avatar
icycalm
Hyperborean
 
Joined: 28 Mar 2006 00:08
Location: Tenerife, Canary Islands

Unread postby icycalm » 27 Jan 2010 19:55

lol, he edited out all the nonsense from the review A WHOLE MONTH AGO without bothering to let me know. I just clicked today on the thread by mistake, otherwise I would never have noticed. Retardation on a rampage, lol.

Banned.
User avatar
icycalm
Hyperborean
 
Joined: 28 Mar 2006 00:08
Location: Tenerife, Canary Islands


Return to Submissions